Advertisement 1

Adam Dodek: Pull back the curtain on the Harper-Trudeau transition

When Canadians could most benefit from shining a light on the constitutional mechanics of responsible government, we have been left in the dark.

Article content

“When will Stephen Harper resign as prime minister?” A week has passed since Justin Trudeau “won” the election and people are still asking this question.

I am quite certain that Harper already has offered his resignation to the Governor General. This conclusion is due to constitutional detective work that I have done rather than reading any public announcement. Sadly, at a time when Canadians could most benefit from shining a light on the constitutional mechanics of responsible government, we have been left in the dark groping to try to figure out what’s happening.

Advertisement 2
Story continues below
Article content

Two people can shine a light on what’s happening: Prime Minister Stephen Harper and Governor General David Johnston. But they haven’t.

Article content

The Governor General and the prime minister have missed a great opportunity to educate Canadians about how our system of government works. Instead, they have remained silent at a critical constitutional moment.

Here is what we can deduce based on past practice and constitutional convention. On election night, Harper publicly conceded defeat to Justin Trudeau. Privately, the next day the prime minister should have called on the Governor General at Rideau Hall to officially advise him of the election results and that consequently he could no longer command the confidence of the newly elected House of Commons when it convenes. Therefore, Harper would have formally tendered his resignation to the Governor General and recommended to him to commission Justin Trudeau to form a government and become prime minister. The resignation would not be effective until just before Justin Trudeau is sworn in as prime minister. This is why Harper remains prime minister now. This is explained in generalities on the Governor General’s website, but it is not enough.

Advertisement 3
Story continues below
Article content

The Governor General should have issued a press release informing Canadians that he had accepted Harper’s resignation and had commissioned Trudeau to form a new government.

Both men missed a critical opportunity to explain to Canadians how our parliamentary democracy works. Harper will not be known for increasing transparency in government. However, he did introduce some positive reforms, such as the creation of an advisory committee on vice-regal appointments (i.e for the Governor General and provincial Lieutenants-Governor). Harper missed an opportunity to make one of his last acts an important one for Canadians’ civic education.

A second opportunity was missed when the Governor General would have contacted Trudeau’s office and requested to meet with Trudeau to formally commission him to form a government and become prime minister. At this point, it became accurate to speak of Trudeau as the “prime minister-designate” because only the Governor General can designate someone to become prime Mmnister. Since the Governor General used this term at the memorial ceremony last Thursday at the National War Memorial, we can assume it is accurate.

Advertisement 4
Story continues below
Article content

We know certainly that Trudeau’s office must have spoken with the Governor General’s office in setting the Nov. 4 date for the swearing in of Justin Trudeau as prime minister. Yet there is no information to this or any related effect on the Governor General’s website.

Osgoode Hall Law School Dean Lorne Sossin and I have previously argued that the Governor General should be far more forthcoming in disclosing the reasons for controversial decisions like contested prorogations. The practice of secrecy surrounding communications between the prime minister and the Governor General is simply no longer justified. Even King and Byng disclosed their correspondence at the time.

Here I am arguing for something far less extreme. The prime minister and the Governor General should simply publicly recognize the formal procedures occurring behind the scenes that facilitate the healthy operation of the system of parliamentary democracy that has served Canadians so well for nearly 150 years.

Canadians are woefully under-informed about how our Constitution works. Our system of government should not be an episode of Murdoch Mysteries left to constitutional experts and pundits to decode.

Adam Dodek is a founding member of the University of Ottawa’s Public Law Group and the author of The Canadian Constitution(Dundurn 2013).

Article content
Comments
You must be logged in to join the discussion or read more comments.
Join the Conversation

Postmedia is committed to maintaining a lively but civil forum for discussion. Please keep comments relevant and respectful. Comments may take up to an hour to appear on the site. You will receive an email if there is a reply to your comment, an update to a thread you follow or if a user you follow comments. Visit our Community Guidelines for more information.

Latest National Stories
    This Week in Flyers